[VL2006] -- VL73: Issues for VoIP on Wi-Fi
ViewsLetter on VoIP
vl2006 at ViewsLetter.com
Sun Mar 29 23:51:47 EDT 2009
We've moved; see footer for new address. Phones remain the same.
*Configuration Issues for VoIP on Wi-Fi*
By William Flanagan
The designs of VoIP and wireless LANs originated separately and at first
didn't consider each other as part of a total network.
* 802.11b, first to deploy, was kept simple by focusing on data
applications.
* VoIP protocols ignored the possibility of a radio link (not to
mention Network Address Translation).
VoIP and Wi-Fi kept bumping into each other in the wiring closet and
data center until each technology had to acknowledge the other. The
result was enhanced protocols and added features:
* VoIP: encryption in IP phones countered the weakness of the WEP,
first air-side algorithm for Wi-Fi.
* Wi-Fi: not only improved encryption (WPA2 uses AES), vLANs, and
authentication, but also added capabilities (with 802.11e) to
assign priority to voice packets.
Now vendors offer VoIP mobile handsets with Wi-Fi radios (some with
cellular too, but that's for another issue). Wireless Access Points can
give priority to the phones, ahead of the PC's data--if you configure
them all properly. In addition to any cellular service setup, there's
the Wi-Fi configuration. Just for starters:
* Service Set Identifier (Extended SSID when configured on an Access
Point); some APs support multiple SSIDs
* virtual LAN ID (in the 802.11Q header)
* Priority class assignments in both IP stack and Wi-Fi
* Encryption protocol and algorithm
* RF channel assignments
* Authentication method (registering the MAC address of a device,
requiring a name/password log in to get on the network, knowing
the SSID, etc.)
* Voice encoding algorithm, most often G.711 (PCM) or G.729 (ACELP)
That last item, the choice of codec, can generate a lot of discussion
related to bandwidth usage and the number of simultaneous voice channels
a link can carry. G.711 encodes at 64,000 bit/s while G.729 compresses
the digital stream to 8,000 bit/s. On a satellite link, when using
header compression to replace the RTP/UDP/IP headers with four bytes or
less, the difference can be significant. In the local area, without
header compression, the situation is not as clear.
Voice is not only real-time, it is constant, equal in both directions,
and demands low latency from the network. To minimize delay at the
source, an IP phone seldom accumulates more than 10 ms of sound before
sending the digital information in a new packet.
G.711 generates 640 bits or 80 bytes in 10 ms, where G.729 outputs 10
bytes. The catch is that either payload requires the same set of
headers, which take 74 bytes for the LAN headers. Encryption adds
another header.
On modern wired LANs, voice usually represents a small fraction of total
traffic. If prioritized ahead of data (with absolute priority) voice
packets "see" a lightly loaded network, encounter minimum delay, and
have no packets dropped due to congestion. Granting top priority to
voice under these conditions can't block or starve data traffic because
each voice channel has only a fixed and relatively low throughput. An IP
phone doesn't burst to high volume the way a file transfer can.
Wi-Fi adds overhead in the form of time delays to allocate air time to
different stations and a necessary wait time between packets on the
radio. With the headers and overhead dominating the air interface, it's
often the large number of small packets that limits the number of voice
channels on an AP and not the encoded bandwidth of the voice payloads.
In their book /Wi-Fi Telephony/ (Newnes/Elsevier, 2007) Chandra and Lide
calculate the number of telephone connections one 802.11b access point
can support without recent improvements in a/g/n Wi-Fi versions or
802.11 enhancements. Even at the shortest range (highest data rate) only
12 calls fit on the 11 Mbit/s channel. The interesting point is that the
difference between G.711 and G.729 is just one connection--10 vs. 11 for
one set of conditions--confirming that codec selection has little impact
on capacity.
You mileage probably varies. Particularly if you have deployed the later
releases of the Wi-Fi standards and radios, you should be able to
support more simultaneous calls per AP. What do you see in your
environment? Let us know and we'll share the aggregate info (or not
yours, if you prefer). Email publisher at viewsletter.com.
___
*How Can Flanagan Consulting Help You?*
We understand not only the technology of networks, but also
the surrounding business processes: procurement, bid
preparation/analysis, statements of work, financial analysis,
consensus building around a solution, and more.
* Find out now: call +1.703.242.8381* or email
*Bill at Flanagan-Consulting.com <mailto:Bill at Flanagan-Consulting.com>*
___
*Flanagan Consulting Supports Litigation Professionals*
Several associates are experienced in analysis of patents, trademarks,
contracts, and other intellectual property related to IT and
communications.
We have assisted attorneys preparing claims, depositions, and testimony.
How can we help you? Queries to +1.703.242.8381.
___
/*Advertise Here*/
/To reach over two thousand interesting people in Telecom and IT./
/For details, //call the Publisher at +1.703.855.0191 /
__
*New Books*
FC Associate Ray Horak recently authored two books on networking.
William Flanagan was the technical editor for both. The books offer
extensive
coverage, and are as accurate as two old pros can make them.
The new titles are:
/Telecommunications and Data Communications Handbook/, 791 pages.
/Webster's New World Telecom Dictionary/, 568 pages.
Wiley is the publisher. Available in bookstores and on the web from
multiple
merchants--do a web search for "Ray Horak" or start with Ray's profile
page at
http://www.amazon.com/gp/pdp/profile/AL7TPWAFURLDA.
__
*Responses to /ViewsLetter/ and Subscriptions*
Mailman, the Linux application, keeps the mailing list. You
can unsubscribe or subscribe at:
http://lists.viewsletter.com/mailman/listinfo/vl2006
NOTE: Migration of the mailing list to a new server required a
temporary change
in the list name. If subscription changes are unavailable, please try
again later
or email the publisher.
You will need a password to unsubscribe, but Mailman
will send you one on request.
Mail is welcome when addressed to publisher at viewsletter.com
<mailto:publisher at viewsletter.com>.
Because of the number of 'out of office' autoreplies, replies to
this message are discarded.
__
*Special thanks* for supporting ViewsLetter to www.webtorials.com
<http://www.webtorials.com/>*,*
your best source for communications tutorials and white papers.
--
Flanagan Consulting
*In Converged Networking
We Have the Experience*
3800 Concorde Parkway, Suite 1500, Chantilly, VA, USA
Ph: +1.703.242.8381 Fx: +1.703.242.8391
*www.Flanagan-Consulting.com*
/Flanagan Consulting is a Service Mark of W. A. Flanagan, Inc. /
"Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance."
--George Bernard Shaw
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.viewsletter.com/pipermail/vl2006/attachments/20090329/98a37a4a/attachment-0001.html
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: VLvoipTinyLogo.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 8614 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.viewsletter.com/pipermail/vl2006/attachments/20090329/98a37a4a/attachment-0002.jpg
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: FCtinyLogo.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 6431 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.viewsletter.com/pipermail/vl2006/attachments/20090329/98a37a4a/attachment-0003.jpg
More information about the VL2006
mailing list